Archiv für die Kategorie ‘Antiquité Tardive’

The transformation of Roman slavery: an economic myth?

Cet article traite de la question de l’esclavage romain en tant que problème dans la tradition du matérialisme historique. Face à l’ampleur exceptionnelle du système esclavagiste romain, les historiens de l’économie ont élaboré des théories tendant à expliquer sa croissance et son développement. Marx et Weber surtout, dans leurs efforts initiaux pour historiciser le développement économique, ont opéré une forte distinction entre les processus pré-capitalistes et capitalistes. Ils ont trouvé, dans la thèse de la conquête, une explication toute prête pour rendre raison de l’expansion de l’esclavagisme romain – cette thèse revenant à considérer que le système esclavagiste romain était la conséquence directe de l’impérialisme romain. Cette vision a eu un sérieux impact sur la perception de la dynamique historique du système et a notamment eu une profonde influence sur la manière dont la « fin » ou « transformation » de l’esclavage a été abordée. Le présent article suggère que les débats contemporains – par exemple les récentes discussions entre Wickham et Banaji – ont été influencés par ces premières tentatives pour distinguer l’esclavagisme romain du capitalisme moderne.

  • Content Type Journal Article
  • Category Original
  • Pages 165-172
  • DOI 10.1484/J.AT.1.103102
  • Authors
    • Kyle Harper

Death in the countryside: some thoughts on the effects of famine and epidemics

Cet article vise à présenter un panorama critique de la recherche actuelle sur l’impact des crises de subsistance et des épidémies sur les populations des campagnes tardo-antiques. Mon intention est d’offrir un état de la question, ainsi que des suggestions pour des recherches futures. Dans cette étude centrée sur l’est de la Méditerranée, l’apport des sources écrites est confrontée aux données des études paléopathologiques récentes qui nous éclairent sur l’état de santé et de nutrition des populations rurales entre le IVeet le VIIIesiècle. La présence de maladies comme la peste, la malaria ou la lèpre est aussi bien évaluée que les états qui prouvent une malnutrition chronique et ses effets sur les populations.

  • Content Type Journal Article
  • Category Original
  • Pages 105-114
  • DOI 10.1484/J.AT.1.103096
  • Authors
    • Dionysios Stathakopoulos

La structure agraire dans l’Empire tardif au miroir du Code Théodosien : quelques observations

The Theodosian Code, which was first enforced in January 439, was meant as a tool to enable lawyers to put an end to ceaseless squabbles caused by a host of confused and obscure texts. After a brief reminder of the models relating to the later Roman Empire as put forward by scholars, this paper aims to deal with three aspects of the judiciary relations between men and land as shown by the constitutions, namely the usurpatio of land, the issue of agri deserti and the ways and means to which the Res privata resorted to make their estates profitable.

  • Content Type Journal Article
  • Category Original
  • Pages 123-135
  • DOI 10.1484/J.AT.1.103098
  • Authors
    • Pierre Jaillette

Questioni di storia agraria tardoromana: schiavi, coloni, villae

Three general issues, which have been recently widely discussed, are relevant to the historical reconstruction of different provincial setups in Late Antiquity.

One issue is whether rural slavery was quantitatively limited everywhere in the Empire and should be included in the free colonate, as scholars mainly argued in past decades, or whether it remained the type of labour more suitable to agricultural systems oriented towards a market economy, thus particularly flourishing in the East during the 4th-5thcentury AD development.

Recent economic and legal historical research has identified colonate not as an organic part of agricultural systems where property did not concentrate on direct production but as a different institution: not a type of land rent but a “contract of employment” where coloni cultivated manorial lands (here again East and Egypt predominate) and were paid by the use of plots of land. Therefore in a kind of “precapitalistic” context the colonic workforce was a salary.

Lastly was the luxurious Late Roman villa (praetorium) mainly the site for accumulation of surpluses produced autonomously in colonic farms or did it keep specific features of the classic model, i.e. resident slaves and direct agricultural production? Were well-known western villas similar to those still to be explored thoroughly in the East?

  • Content Type Journal Article
  • Category Original
  • Pages 115-122
  • DOI 10.1484/J.AT.1.103097
  • Authors
    • Domenico Vera

Paesaggi in equilibrio: uomo e acqua nella Pianura Padana Centrale tra IV e IX secolo

In the Middle Ages, the Po Valley was a large wetland, shaped by large marshes and forests, alternating with waterways and strips of dry land. In this paper we consider: 1/ transformation of rural settlements in relation to wetlands; 2/ environmental aspects and their transformations in Early Middle Ages; 3/ the way of living in wetlands area; 4/ the organization of lived space and the definition of places; 5/ theoretical and methodological implications of the different approaches and the perspectives of historical and archaeological research.

We examine the hydrological changes which occurred between the 6thand 7thcenturies, as well as the material culture of settlements which arise in the Early Middle Ages (6th-9thcentury) in contact with wetlands. We would like to show what kind of common processes affect lowland areas: the landscapes are much changed from Roman period (1st-2dcentury), and a decrease of the population has to be observed as well as a transformation in location strategies for settlements (Nogara, Comacchio, Ferrara).

The study also presents a preliminary examination of the environment, as revealed by recent studies on the considered area, like Cava Pedocca, Nogara, etc. Wetlands come indeed into the redefinition of the population between Late Roman Period and Early Middle Ages, as settlements up to the 9thcentury are closely in contact with these zones.

Management and exploitation of the lowlands, as it is, make us think wetland and woodland areas less marginal as expected. On the contrary, it leads us to think about an economic and cultural system where wetlands, forests and waterways are essential to settlements. Finally, all these seem to also show the theoretical implications on the organization of archaeological research and interpretation models resulting.

  • Content Type Journal Article
  • Category Original
  • Pages 47-67
  • DOI 10.1484/J.AT.1.103092
  • Authors
    • Fabio Saggioro

Apports de l’anthropologie en matière de démographie et de dynamique d’occupation des sols dans l’Occident des IVe-VIIIe siècles

The question of identity of populations, like the study of migratory movements, form the subject of debates for a long time between scientific communities. Based on their respective data sources, historians, archaeologists and anthropologists have tried, separately, to distinguish between the migration of peoples and the diffusion of cultures, without anyone hangs on truly the conviction. Although studies of ancient DNA show great promise, the analysis of the dynamics of settlements currently rests priorily on archaeological and anthropological data to which one can now, thanks to the development of new tools, include a paleodemographic approach. However, this analysis must be done in a joint approach among these disciplines. One will see that, in spite of the imperfections of the samples, it is possible to find arguments attesting to the existence of population movements and that, under certain conditions, a dynamic approach of the evolution of a population is possible at the scale of the quarter century.

  • Content Type Journal Article
  • Category Original
  • Pages 75-85
  • DOI 10.1484/J.AT.1.103094
  • Authors
    • Luc Buchet

Évolution démographique et modes d’occupation du sol en Syrie du Nord : les cas du Ǧebel Waṣṭāni, du Ğebel Zāwiye et des Marges arides (IIe-VIIe s.)

The three papers presented here sum up some of the results achieved by three archeological missions in Northern Syria. Focusing mainly on settlement and occupation dynamics, these contributions are dealing with methodological approaches dictated by geographical and archaeological features in each area: Ǧebel Waṣṭāni, Ğebel Zāwiye and northern Syria’s steppes. They successfully draw out common occupation patterns in these regions during Late Antiquity.

B. Riba, Démographie et dynamique de l’occupation du Ǧebel Waṣṭāni dans le Massif calcaire de la Syrie du Nord (IIe-VIe siècles)

The interest in the archaeological heritage of the Ǧebel Waṣṭāni, in the Limestone Massif of northern Syria, is fairly recent despite the privileged position of the ridge between Antioch and Apamea. Following the surveys carried out by Franciscans in the 1980s, several research surveys were conducted from 2002 as part of the “Syrian Mission of Banassara and Ǧebel Waṣṭāni”. They were undertaken over the whole mountain range, and in particular at the sites Banassara and Kefert Ἁqab. Currently, these surveys allow us to understand the conditions of settlement of Gebel Wastani, the characteristics of the implementation of rural housing, and the modes of development of village communities in the Roman and Byzantine periods. They are also an opportunity to consider the place of the ridge in the general evolution of the Limestone Massif.

C. Duvette, Le Ğebel Zāwiye (Massif calcaire de la Syrie du Nord) : l’architecture domestique reflet d’une évolution démographique

More than 200 rural settlements reflect the attractiveness of the Ğebel Zāwiye, the southernmost and largest of the limestone hills of northern Syria, between the 2nd and the 6th century AD. The growing population of this region during this period mainly resulted in the development of villages surrounded by agricultural parcels. We have an image still virtually intact of these rural settlements in some areas, and a description of their development is possible in terms of individual and related growth processes. The evolution of domestic architecture is one of the focuses of these studies.

M. Rivoal, Les fluctuations du peuplement antique dans la steppe de Syrie du Nord en question (IIe-VIIe siècle)

From the beginning of the Roman period, the steppe’s fringe of Northern Syria experienced a strong sedentary expansion eastwards which reached its peak towards the end of Byzantine period. During the last two decades, the “Arid Margins Survey” has drawn a vivid picture of this gradual conquest. However, many questions remain beyond the reach of surface surveys, such as occupancy duration or differences between Roman, Byzantine or Umayyad occupation on a same site. The very phenomenon of this expansion is still to be understood. It may have involved massive immigration of sedentary people from neighboring countries as much as nomad herder’s settling down.

  • Content Type Journal Article
  • Category Original
  • Pages 87-104
  • DOI 10.1484/J.AT.1.103095
  • Authors
    • Catherine Duvette
    • Bertrand Riba
    • Marion Rivoal
    • Gérard Charpentier
    • Bernard Geyer

The paradoxes of Late Antiquity: a thermodynamic solution

La période du Bas-Empire du IIIeau VIIesiècle connaît beaucoup de contradictions paradoxales dans ce que l’on peut reconstruire de l’archéologie, de l’art et de l’histoire. Cet article résume ces aspects et suggère une façon d’expliquer ces paradoxes, à travers des modèles mathématiques et thermodynamiques.

  • Content Type Journal Article
  • Category Original
  • Pages 69-73
  • DOI 10.1484/J.AT.1.103093
  • Authors
    • John Bintliff

Front Matter („Editorial board“, „Title page“, „Principales abréviations“, Table of contents“, „Éditorial“)

Front Matter („Editorial board“, „Title page“, „Principales abréviations“, Table of contents“, „Éditorial“)

  • Content Type Journal Article
  • Category Original
  • Pages 1-10

Introduction

The study of the ancient countryside started in the 19thcentury, when the textes of the Roman land surveyors were published. Researches began on towns’ territories and their limitatio, expanding afterwards to the problems of agrarian structures and of the ways of soil exploitation. As far as Late Antiquity is concerned, the countryside shared the negative image attached to the period, all the more dark this image, that the one of the prievious centuries was idealized. Following some topoi of the written sources, but without any sound argument, the prevalent opinion was that the countryside was exposed to stagnation of the production, depopulation due to epidemics and climatic reverses, and abandonment of settlements. More recently, a more critical appraisal of written sources and the development of archaeological researches have opened new perspectives, taking into account the achievements of historical geography, paleo-climatology, paleo-anthropology. The result is a complex picture, made of lights and shadows, with many regional differences. The two dossiers (2012 and 2013 issues of the Revue) consider some important open questions, through both general / methodological papers and case studies on the Western and Eastern part of the Roman world.

  • Content Type Journal Article
  • Category Original
  • Pages 13-23
  • DOI 10.1484/J.AT.1.103090
  • Authors
    • Gisella Cantino Wataghin
    • Hervé Inglebert